What's more important for Lightning?
A) Punishment for bad behaviour when someone tries to steal
B) No risk of losing all funds in a channel due to a freak accident
Discussion
classic case of why not both?
Both are mutually exclusive, that's the catch 🤙
Although a middle ground is possible (you don't have to have 100% punishments, 0% risk etc).
Great question. They talked about this briefly on the most recent Chaincode podcast. I think probably the latter.
Like #[2] said, por que no los dos?
It depends on what's going on, I think. From a technical viewpoint, how might the two scenarios be distinct?
Tough choice … as it’s unknown how many A) would occur if there is no punishment.. though I like eltoo and I’m hoping this gets implemented I understand there is a risk there
B