Nostr clients should block content from accounts with invalid NIP-05 entries.
WTF is the point of having them if we don't enforce their validity?
Discussion
I don't understand how is this not implemented yet.
Need spam replies have been hidden
100% agree.
At least the top clients like primal, amethyst, snort.
Or make it an option at the very least.
The human readable profile is far and away more useful bit of NIP5. Validation is nearly useless unless it's an established brand/domain. Anyone with domain can make nip5s valid. We saw this with services like nostrcheck.me and others that now have expired domain but hey they charged 10k for an entry in a json and made some money before going away.
Hello 😀
Nostrcheck.me has not charged a single sat to anyone; the goal was always to bring Nostr closer to people and try nostrcheck-server in a production environment . Please, don’t lump us together with others. We are still online and offering help to anyone who needs it 💜
On the other hand, it is legitimate to charge for your services, and I don't understand the criticism. In fact, charging is a form of Proof of work.
Yes nostr:nprofile1qqsgnc2tuj0dqpea4qak0qnee55m5kkcdncqpd4r6xjv8hz25n7aqtqpzemhxue69uhhyetvv9ujumn0wd68ytnzv9hxgqgewaehxw309ac8junpd45kgtnxd9shg6npvchxxmmdqyg8wumn8ghj7vf5xqhxvdm69e5k7mm3qfz that's right. I used an example but not a good one for my explanation. I've been very happy with your site. I can always write my own key converter but I've used you're so many times it's ridiculous. Nostrcheck has been a s great service provider imo.
I meant nostr verified and other verification services. Nostr check is still around and a great tool. Thanks nostr:nprofile1qqsgnc2tuj0dqpea4qak0qnee55m5kkcdncqpd4r6xjv8hz25n7aqtqpzemhxue69uhhyetvv9ujumn0wd68ytnzv9hxgqgewaehxw309ac8junpd45kgtnxd9shg6npvchxxmmdqyg8wumn8ghj7vf5xqhxvdm69e5k7mm3qfz. No criticism from me on your service.
💜💜💜
This is not a good idea imo. You're going to block out a ton of people and a NIP5 isn't necessary for validation. We already have public keys.
Block no nip05 is different from block invalid nip05.
My npub is all you need
Right. I think the OP was about having an invalid nip 05 which is what the impersonator spam accounts have to confuse people. Not having a nip 05 isn't the same as having an invalid one. Maybe I'm wrong
No. That side of the internet is permissioned. Me don't like.
Haters gonna hate. Keep it up 💜🤣🙏
We all have our roles. Zero shame nor judgement from my view.
NIP-05 proves a pubkey is associated with a DNS domain name. what does that have to do with content?
A spammer could duplicate everything about your profile except that, right?
lmao, well the little server I use to host my nip5 crashes sometimes and I'm too lazy to fix
why isn't ok to just show it's not working?
It should at least be an option
It might create an attack vector, though. Users could effectively be muted by taking out their nip5 server.
I agee completely..
The ability to mute invalid nip05 by domains would be a welcome addition in the arsenal of tools to block spam on the client.
Would be interesting to have relays that only send notes from valid nip05 just like wot relays which exists
I think I have mine setup properly finally, would someone be able to confirm I got it right? I may transition to using the root, but for now, I just want to make sure it is compliant for nip-05. I also know I did not include relays, yet. It is on the list of todo.
Yep, looks good 👌
how do I find my nip 05 address?