Thanks for the advice! I plan to do pencil and paper at first because we aren't big fans of having our kids on technology, but I'm sure in a few years we'll look into digital programs.
Discussion
We found a place in Houston called The Homeschool Store. It's basically a small warehouse full of every schooling resource you could ever need, and all in physical media.
In our case, we're coupling school with coding and learning Linux, so the online program meshes with that. I feel you on the tech stuff, though. It takes constant vigilance to maintain a balance.