Replying to Avatar Kruw

Whirlpool leaves deterministic links because it peels the change during the tx0 used to create sized equal outputs. I just unmixed the Whirlpool transaction from your screenshot to reveal the change: https://mempool.space/tx/323df21f0b0756f98336437aa3d2fb87e02b59f1946b714a7b09df04d429dec2

Address bc1qgwv9hn979rex0rhfp3cknfdkyrgk04493gclvv belonging to Whirlpool input 1 created 0.01346981 BTC in traceable change which has 100% deterministic links to bc1qjy3zud5c7qypvgccgvptvaxkcsg6g4jl3u4tdy

Address bc1q528pyda90y4j9nuqrcm65rlxz9txljtn208dqm belonging to Whirlpool input 3 created 0.01971146 BTC in traceable change which has 100% deterministic links to bc1q50akm6ggcwgjext09tuz0rcl6cya2huu70pef4

Feel free to post any other Whirlpool tx ids and I'll unmix them too.

You are referencing normal tx. Not a coinjoin tx. Not a whirlpool tx. No shit there are deterministic links. Water is wet.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Tx0 creates doxxic change, which can be sent to whirlpool again so what deterministic links are you talking about? If doxxic change too small for the pool size Samourai wallet let’s yuu freeze it so one can’t spend it anymore it’s actually automated and one must do manual unfreezing to even be able to spend it. It does not create 100% deterministic links unless one combines it with another doxxic change that came from a difference source. You do not understand how tx0 works in Samourai wallet. Stop spreading lies!

When you send the toxic change to a smaller pool and pay the coordinator fee again, this doesn't eliminate the toxic waste, it just makes the waste smaller.

This is why Whirlpool's coordinator needs to upgrade to WabiSabi so the toxic change is never created at all.

I'm not referencing a "normal tx", I'm referencing the tx0 self spend that creates the equal sized outputs that entered the Whirlpool transaction.

You say "no shit there are deterministic links in Whirlpool" which is why I'm asking: "Why don't you upgrade to WabiSabi coinjoins so you never create these deterministic links?"

TxO is not a coinjoin tx

I know tx0s are not coinjoin transactions, they are self spend transactions, which is why they reveal a 100% deterministic link to the change.

WabiSabi makes EVERY spend a coinjoin- You never lose your privacy at all since no toxic change is ever created.