Already the fact that AI art is called AI art makes it clear that it is not art.
Just as AI photography is not photography.
Whether or not it can be liked is another matter.
#my2sats
Discussion
AI has no place in the arts. Any form of art.
What about as a tool to create a template for someone? Or to learn about art? What if someone wants to use Ai to review or edit their writing?
If someone has to use it to edit their writing then they’re not a writer.
Editor is litterally a job. They're replacing the expensive 3rd party.
You are confusing the job of an editor, with the verb edit in software.
... but that whalephant... 😜
It’s hard for me to say to an artist that the generated thing is art, so I think about it in the context of my field… is generated UX still user design? I think the answer is Yes. I’ve asked lls to think of the best UX and they definitely try. Usually the result is not great - but some of that could be due to my poor inputs and lack of context. “Reasoning” LLMs may be much better, we’ll see. But even today I’d classify the outputs as generated UX designs.
Bonjour,
Ce débat est vraiment riche et profond. Dans la langue francaise, Je remarque une similitude marquante entre les termes prompt et dompter... l "artiste" qui génére des images par l ia à l aide de prompt ressemble au travail du dompteur qui va faire réaliser des prouesses à l'animal, le résultat sera spectaculaire, le public sera enchanté, ebloui, subjugué... l'art ia ne serait il pas très proche de l'art du cirque?
Au debut j'etais subjugué par les images ia, puis peu à peu lassé, ennuyé par ces productions... définitivement je prefére voir les animaux dans leurs milieux naturels que derrière des barreaux.
Yeah, yeah, and Lino Art is not art because it is called Lino Art... It is in fact just damaged linoleum. 🤣
Same with LLMs. They are not thinking, or reasoning (also not the new openai model) it's just pattern recognition and slight variations for generation. I'm in shock looking what companies currently think they should/can do with "AI".