I feel like the straight boosting of a root note is a bit of a faux pas. This is especially true when the note is big/long or if the noter is well followed (eg Odell, Jack, Gigi).

The clear exceptions I can see (there may be more - context is key):

- an old, forgotten note that you think is relevant

- a reply note that has value on it's own (without context)

- a new verified Nostr user that doesn't have a following yet

- if you're going to add some context agree or diagree (quote note)

You can do it, but if you keep cluttering my feed, I'll eventually either quietly unfollow you or mute you. I'm pretty tolerant & it would take a lot for me to get to that point, but we all have a line. We've also all probably done it & there are no take backs here.

There will be a bit of an eternal September as Nostr goes parabolic & we create our unique culture.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

How do you quote note?

I copy the note ID, type out my note & on a new line stick an @ symbol and then paste in the note ID.

Each client will render this slightly differently, but it seems pretty solid:

#[1]

Like this

@note1gjw0mf40vnpdfgr6qpucjkqtzazk2vvsxrt40vafmsr2yu683h6qw07xuy

Bit of a pain in the ass, but it worked. 👍

FWIW, Nostrgram does the work for you - like twatter. Just have to hit the quote icon. As #[2] mentioned, each client will render in its own way.

I think quote noting under an existing note is problematic in Amethyst.

The rendered results are unexpected for me 😂

I'm glad they look ok in your client though.

#[7] - not sure you're aware of this glitch

You make a good point here and I agree - boosting on nostr feels a bit different. I do tend to boost (without comment) notes sometimes but I typically do so while matching one of your above criteria. That said, what's one person's old relevant note or a note containing value w/o context is another's spam.🤔 I'll definitely have to strongly consider future commentless boosts more carefully.

Yup - it's definitely different. 👍

My intention wasn't to make anyone feel bad & I'm certainly not after apologies or arguments.

We all still learning what this thing is.

I'm just a little eager for October to roll in 😂