How do I get back the default "heart" emoji (or Like icon) on #Amethyst ? It's gone and all I could find are the fancy ones with gradient after reinstalling. #asknostr

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Add a + as a reaction

Thanks!!! It works!

You're welcome and thanks for the sats ^^

Just keep in mind the + is not a like. Many other clients use it as an UP Vote ⬆️. Adding an up vote without also adding the DOWN vote might break their stats. that's why we are not using it anymore.

Oh.. thank you for the clarification! And for building Amethyst too! 🔥🔥🔥

That's not what NIP 25 says

Like I said in our call, every NIP is wrong. :)

I have had long discussions about this +/- encoding and I concluded that it is better to not interfere with UP/Down vote clients.

Otherwise, the weight of Amethyst in their stats breaks everything.

I remember this conversation, my comment was that there are at least 3 semantics for voting packed into one. Partitioning by content won't fix it, we need new kinds.

probably

+ is definitely a like & upvote

The two should have never been the same encode. They are not the same reaction. Clients do not use them in the same way. Semantics are all different.

It's just wrong.

I didn’t really like it either, someone suggested it and i didn’t want to argue so i added it in. A spec is a spec though.

Sure, a spec is a spec. But the same spec also allow any other reaction, which I prefer to focus at. In that way, those debating if + should be a like or an upvote can sort themselves out without our interference.