I agree in general. Orwell I would say seemed a pretty decent guy as far as it goes, and I've no problem with forgiving people for saying stupid things, I agree with you we need much more of that.

But there is a line. Has to be. Timothy C. May was just completely bonkers unhinged, and Chomsky, being fully aware of the underage girls, I mean come on.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

For me that line is probably different... it's being "evil" in a malicious or sadistic sense - actually causing harm to people, enjoying their suffering, deliberately destroying lives. Hitler, Stalin, Pol Pot, Putin - but not just mass murderers, also the everyday sadists and abusers who get off on hurting others.

Timothy C May was obviously intentionally provocative and later paranoid, but I don't believe he was evil in that sense. And that Chomsky became friends at his 84 years (!) with some malicious person - that doesn't prove anything about his life's work or ideas.

I really don't think this digging into people's pasts makes sense.