Are badges the Shitcoin of Nostr?

Right now, people are having fun creating badges, awarding badges, and of course receiving badges. Anyone can create them for any reason. Anyone can apply a value for them. There's an infinite supply of them. If this sounds familiar, that's because it's all of Bitcoiners counter-arguements against Shitcoins and NFTs. (We've all said these things.)

Badges aren't intended to be used in this capacity though. Badges are meant to be useful indicators. For example: If you're attending a conference, you'll be awarded a badge. If you're an early adopter of a specific relay, you're awarded a badge. If you're an early adopter or beta tester of a specific Nostr client, you're awarded a badge.

Eventually, badge recipients will be able to display their badges on their profiles. Clients will be able to choose which badges or even which badge providers they want to allow.

Eventually, badges will be reputation based and seem less Shitcoin-esque. Right now, people are just having fun, exploring a new feature.

So, let'em have fun! 🤙

Badges can't be traded. There's no harm in them. Plus, and this is a big plus, there's no fucking Shitcoin associated with them.

(That said, if someone were to charge X amounts of sats for a badge on an external website, there's no stopping anyone from doing this. It's an open protocol. Stay frosty.)

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

They don’t claim to have monetary value so whatev

Not yet. I'm sure someone will sell an "Orange Check" at some point, essentially #[3]'s idea.

Same view. Keep it light and fun. If it gets shitcoin adjacent I’m out. 💯

So you don't want to buy 1 of 100 minted Nostrich Punk Badges? 🤣

Non-fungible badge shiten

OVER MY DEAD BODY DEREK lol

I’m a little conflicted about the idea of selling badges. I don’t think it’s quite like shitcoining because it’s not like you’re being sold a lie that your badge is going to be worth millions someday. I still wouldn’t pay money for one though

Agree. They're more like service indicators.

Proof of being THERE….and fun🤙

Proof of There sounds like a new protocol. Wen token?

Social tokens 😖

I dont like this

And that's you're right. 🤙

They remind me of the OG counterparty rare pepes. The thing is, post NFT-mania, the only way to have fun like they used to when they knew they weren't worth anything is to make them unsellable, which is what these are.

I guess that’s the beauty of it though, don’t like badges? Use a different client 🤙

Exactly.

Also this @* Osho/Rajneesh voice*

Open protocols are of the people, by the people, for the people.

But the people are

Crap, was meant to be a quote note

How does one acquire these badges

People are creating them on badges.page right now, but any website could do the same thing.

Sorry for so many noob questions, but where do the badges go? Are they displayed by your username/npub like the verification ones are, or is it just something where others can check if your account really has one or not?

I made one for people who post regularly to #nostrfitness

I’ve got to get my act together and qualify for that one 🤙

LFG!

NIP-58 means: future #[0] badges 🎉

grateful to #[1]​ for its development

cc: #[2]​

#[3]

there’s a nostrica attendee badge out there :)

Thanks for the S/O #[4]​ ⚡️

Hope there’s one for virtual attendees 🥹

I just awarded you the 5000 sat badge which does have value. 🫡💜

Badgers just wanna have fun 💜

Given that there is no consensus or scarcity built into nostr it seems like the perfect place for stuff like this. The biggest problem with NFTs was people trying to claim they were scarce because they were on a blockchain. So yeah, badges are similar, but so very different at the same time.

I've had an idea for decentralized authority for food production standards, and it seems that Nostr+badges might be a good protocol on which to build it! This would be sort of like L2 on nostr in that it would work on top of it. I imagine a local organization would authorize people to qualify (or disqualify) a source as a clean and reputable producer or distributor of food based on local standards and values (such as different levels of organic produce, specific exclusions, practices, etc.). This would also serve to make finding the food at the quality you want easier and more locally.

The immediate application is food, but the same idea would work for auto repair shops, professional services, construction and maintenance contractors, plumbers/electricians/roofers/handymen, etc, like a more specific version of yelp or Google reviews that is locally controlled.

Could be like "Nostr guilds" or some such name.

I like the idea.

Also, what about calling them Flocks? You know, the whole bird theme?

call them nostr herds

We're birds, not cattle!

lol that was what i thought but i looked it up and ostriches in a group are called herds!

whaaaat? today i learned. thank you.

Interesting! Must be because they're large flightless animals, so whoever was naming them thought "herd" captured the visual of a group of large land animals.

New Adjustable Zap works nice

Hey! I like it! Good name.

#[4]​ check this out.

Just here for the memes. 🤓