Avatar
hasky
177bfd1640883bcf86e5028843ef069094e75e8a12eed156958ddf6b347a07e4
Nostr , web3 , NFT, Bitcoin , freedom tech .
Replying to Avatar fiatjaf

# Nostr is pro-censorship

In [Keys are meaningless](nostr:naddr1qqyxxc35vdsngdmpqyghwumn8ghj7enfv96x5ctx9e3k7mgzyqalp33lewf5vdq847t6te0wvnags0gs0mu72kz8938tn24wlfze6qcyqqq823cs34ccf) we hopefully made it clear that keys are not central to Nostr's idea, in fact keys are just an unnecessary burden that enables something much more important: relays.

The fact that one user, through their client, can reach out to a huge number of these servers hosted anywhere, and that each user can publish their stuff to any of them, from a modest server at his basement to a big cloud relay hosted by a big company, without anyone having to trust any of these: this is the core of the Nostr idea.

And the fact that Nostr relies on an open ecosystem of privately-owned relay servers is the only thing that ensures a proper incentive structure and gives it a chance of working: while other centralized platforms and protocols in the past -- even those that have tried to be very open and anti-censorship -- ended up struggling against what whom or what should be allowed to be published or not -- because after all they relied on a big common "global" pool of messages that had to be interpreted by apps.

That reliance kills the entire idea because at the very least someone has to host the content, and hosting that content has a cost, it has moral implications and also legal implications, so at some point someone, somewhere, has to make a decision to stop hosting some things, or restricting some users from publishing and so on, and there will never be a global agreement between all the peoples of the Earth about whom or what should be allowed and what should be disallowed. Even a rate-limit, IP blocking or other naïve measures that a server must necessarily take in order to survive on the internet, are a form of "censorship".

On Nostr none of that is a factor because each relay is independent of each other and there is no global pool of content, by definition. Because of that, and because it's the job of the readers to figure out from where to read, no relay has any obligations to please all the peoples of the Earth and is free to impose any limits or policies it wants.

Of course all of that breaks down if apps relinquish their obligation to figure out what relays to read from and decide to read from a static list of relays, but that should have gone without saying.

## See also

- [Constant](npub1t6jxfqz9hv0lygn9thwndekuahwyxkgvycyscjrtauuw73gd5k7sqvksrw)'s [video explanation](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K5oXaW1EqbE)

thank you for writing . Nostr is barefront layer of anti censorship .

Replying to Avatar _

Nom

Nom 😋

Replying to Avatar Gigi

GM

Good moooooorning 🤩

How do you test this ting ? Can public audience test it ? If so where and how ? Developer have tools to test thing, what about public ? Should we make a platform on Nostr where general public audience can test apps ? It gives the power of apps to people … and not to company or bussiness ☺️

anyone ever publish site on obsidian.md ? if so , how was it ? #nostr

#nostr #motivational

Good morning friends , enemies and colleagues alike , you all get good morning from me ♥️

Replying to Avatar jb55

home

Have safe trip 👍

#nostr #motivational

Replying to Avatar zach

Nature

It seems so green and nice to have shadows under the tree on hot summer day . Where is this park ?

if unverified user keep posting vigourously sharing link , looks suspicious , should we report them or mute them ?

Replying to Avatar zach

patience

The best advice ever . Short but comprehends all things . Is like the answer of everything 😍

The world recognising Palestine #Palestine #freedom

I always think the main problem of relay is the slow performance.

It’s simply because the more people using the same relay , the more traffic and heavy the capacity and it slow down the relay .

I could be wrong .

#News #Tsunami

ALERT : MAJOR TSUNAMI Hits Russia Kuril Island .

#news #USA #Trump

BREAKING : The Senate voted Tuesday night to confirm Emil Bove as a federal appeals court judge

The Senate confirmed Emil Bove as a federal appeals court judge with a 50-49 vote, despite whistleblower complaints alleging he prioritized Trump’s agenda over legal principles. Sens. Murkowski and Collins joined Democrats in opposing Bove, who was nominated for the 3rd Circuit. Allegations include misleading senators and ignoring court orders.

image credited to The Washington Post , i just screenshot .

I am here to find friends but it seems

Everyone anonymous including me so kind of difficult 🤣