Will we ever see relays automatically banning people based on report events?

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Surely that could be abused

Every relay can run their own rules so yeah, I expect this

I just assume if its possible, it will be tried.

Not automatically though, maybe after ridiculously repetitive reports

sounds mastodon like

Without blocking of users based on certain criteria (bots, child porn, etc) NOSTR would not be useable. This is simply reality. The good relays and the good clients are already blocking bots and awful content by the thousands. #grownostr.

Perhaps we can just accept there will always be gazillions of bots but we have an option to add other profile mutes of people we follow.

So for example I always Mute & Report crap I don’t want to see (Majority is Spam) so perhaps we as users have the option to once follow someone we like, we can also “add” all of that profiles muted accounts onto our own list. This way we have community marking spam and we could easily have own mute lists updated by copying the list of mutes from other users that we know have similar tolerance levels etc.

This way it encourages users to work together maintaining spam lists. and if you follow someone you will both have similar filters to cut out rubbish… It’s only the users who don’t follow you who see the rubbish… That Nostr itself is unable to clear everything …

Or something along those lines anyways.

To be clear, this isn’t possible today, right?

But, why?

It's inevitable, but automatic banning on the client would be better.

Hell no but some kind of pre moderation based AI could help relay operator

If you use NOSTR.band you are already using a relay which auto bans massive numbers of users. This is why it is the best relay and used by 99% of NOSTR users. Wine also has sophisticated blocking. #grownostr

Relays are already blocking massive numbers of accounts. If they weren't NOSTR would be a spam filled wasteland. NOSTR.band has sophisticated spam filtering techniques based on pagerank type algorithms and "trusted" users. This is why their feed is basically "clean". Your question might be if relays will ban users based on the report from One other user, or based on multiple reports. I think relays and clients are already banning many users based on One or multiple reports. For instance Child Porn is banned instantly by any good client or relay. Clients or relays who don't ban criminal behaviour will not succeed. #grownostr

how the fuck does a client decide 'illegal' behaviour?

Upset the propaganda. Fight the law.

🤭

Guess with all that propaganda going, Ryska Posten must have come as a surprise no doubt.

nostr:npub1qrtyq4cj47l34fahmudu8xppuenfvdv5a6ggs0le7m8jz4ct2yrqykc6q7

We'll definitely get there. But hopefully by then every second user will have his own relay and the top 25 will not be able to dictate or hide anything.

all things seem possible on nostr and this seems likely

Bad actors could setup a massive set of relays that are actively censoring?

I assume most relays will be paid/whitelisted

Yes I think so

nostr.mom does that. I don't add it to nos.lol because I want it to be more inclusive.