I need a new sci-fi show to watch. Which of these two is better in your opinion?

Foundation

Silo

I've read and loved the books for both series, so I'm prepared to be disappointed either way ๐Ÿ˜‚

#asknostr

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

Iโ€™ve never read Silo but I donโ€™t think Foundation stayed true to the plot at all. So Silo.

I'm less attached to Silo, The Foundation series is kind of like LOTR to me. I'm kind of leaning in Silo's direction already.

I struggled to follow how Appleโ€™s Foundation was related to Asimovโ€™s books. Silo is pretty good though (caveat, I never read the books)!

Silo seems much easier to adapt. Foundation is such an epic sprawling story when you take all 5 novels into account.

silo

It's taking the lead ๐Ÿš€

Idk but foundation has a more interesting cover

silo, gave up foundation after like 5 episodes

Silo

Silo all the way!

Silo was pretty good.

Bit Fallout vibes

Foundation

The first to pick foundation ๐Ÿ‘€

Any particular reason?

Silo is better as a book, I hate how the show portrayed it

Yeah I've read them both. I haven't watched either because I don't wan to walk into a disappointment ๐Ÿ˜…

I think Foundation is a lesser disappointment, but after reading itโ€™s still bound to be to some extent

Foundation seems like it would be impossible, on par with Tolkien stuff.

*Gets ready to watch Deep Space Nine again*

๐Ÿ˜ญ๐Ÿคฃ

I think LoTR was done very well. Donโ€™t expect LoTR level though ๐Ÿ˜‚

Yes Jackson's trilogy was amazing. I've read those books multiple times, and the movies are almost perfect. I don't expect nearly as much from Hollywood these days.

Neither. Read the Foundation Books.

Or read anything by Philip K Dick.

Haven't watched Foundation but Silo was amazing