If you can be persuaded by Nazis to read Hitlers book and defend it, maybe there’s an acceptable reason for a Jew to come to his conclusions about Israel? Honestly I’ve had that book recommended to me by someone who is not a Nazi as a way to consider other points of view. I’ve found too many more constructive ways of doing that to spend time reading it, but I don’t think it’s necessary a bad thing to do. I certainly don’t have first or even second hand knowledge of what is really going on over there and can see intelligent people be very wrong about what is going on in my own town. My point was that you and that other guy are being very hard on someone who has good reason to have the views he has and I don’t see any evidence that you have access to anything information that he doesn’t. He seems plenty capable of verifying information in other areas and my only questioning of his views is the ability to objectively view the situation. Don’t radicalize people further for dismissing their primary knowledge because you think they should have come to a different view.