I read Upgrade by Blake Crouch and wasn't a big fan. The outline of the story was promising but the execution was inconsistent, in my view. I'd give it maybe a 6.5/10.

It's set in the near future, with a specific event having messed everything up. A genius scientist that tried to solve world hunger by genetically modifying crops accidentally caused a global famine, killing 200 million and damaging the world economically and socially for decades in a way that it never fully recovered from. Gene editing is now forbidden, and since the technology is accessible at pretty low cost, there are police forces dedicated to surveilling for usage of it and raiding peoples' houses to prevent another catastrophe.

The main character, the son of that scientist, gets infected with a disease that changes his genes and makes him superhuman mentally and physically in a world where that's outlawed. And thus his adventure begins to find out who infected him and what to do.

Without giving spoilers, probably my main issue with the story was the villain. She was badass with a cool background and setup, but then her motivations didn't really make sense. And the majority of the book is about the philosophical and external conflict between the hero and this villain. Solid outline and idea, but felt rushed and not as well thought out as it could have been. Some elements felt preachy in the sense that it feels like the author set up this conflict, which didn't really need to happen, in order to make a point. By fine-tuning the plot a bit more, I think it could have been executed better and more believably and preserving the overall outline.

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

My wife and I concur. Both of us were excited for it, but it just didn't hit.

"Daemon" by Daniel Suarez was great, if youre looking for another book in the same vein.

iโ€™m looking forward to the sci-fi panel at the conf this year.

nevent1qqsvu3a7ryew6j7dmk9r8y0fycyfddamv7h3qp97rfj4sfhu594gf8q6xemt5

Interesting.

Lyn, as someone just getting into these types of books. Anything you recommend to start my collection? The premise of this one seems interesting, so maybe something similar.

Sci fi specifically, or sci fi, fantasy, and speculative fiction broadly?

The Lies of Locke Lamora is great fantasy, imo. For sci fi Iโ€™m enjoying the Sun Eater series.

Did you read Dungeon Crawler Carl? Most fun book Iโ€™ve read in a while, although youโ€™ll lose some brain cells

Have you read Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell by Susanna Clarke? 10/10 so far for me. Holy smokes.

I think I stopped reading Crouch because of the preachy-ness.

Havenโ€™t read this one, but I will likely concur.

Just started this after reading Dark Matter which I was a huge fan of. Heโ€™s got a captivating flow to his work.

Have you read his Recursion? I actually like that one a lot. Even more than dark matter.

Also Lyn, not sure if youโ€™ve read these yet, but I also canโ€™t recommend enough Ted Chiangs two books of sci-fi short stories, and also Project Hail Mary by Andy weir.

Stories of Your Life? โ€ฆ thatโ€™s the one I have by Ted Chiang. Hail Mary is sooo good. Such a comfort read and makes me want breakfast burritos.

Ya the other one is called exhalation I think.

oh my god, haha for a sec. I got confused because your response sounded like what I was talking about in another comment thread. In that one, the topic was โ€˜inspirationโ€™.

btw, thanks for the title. Interested in checking out from the libraryโ€ฆ ๐Ÿ“š

Just finished listening to Project Hail Mary on Audible. It was amazing ๐Ÿ˜š ๐Ÿ‘Œ loved it so much!

Thanks for the reminder to check out Ted Chiang

The narration for rocky is great on audible

The reader just did an overall perfect job. Makes me want to check out more stuff he read just because he read it.

Yes that narrator is well know for being a good one.

Thanks for the insight!

All his stuff is meh. Interesting ideas poorly executed.

The plot doesn't look bad. But I trust you that it's a barely enough book