Guys...I had an idea recently that I've been simmering on, and I think I might be onto something big here.

The zapping ecosystem unlocks infinite possibilities for expertise-seekers and expertise-providers to meet for a win-win transaction. But I feel like we haven't even scratched the surface on this in terms of building out an ecosystem of P2P micro-economies through the use of the "#Ask_____" hashtag format.

Imagine... experts of all types, across all fields, aggregating around hashtags according to their skillset, so they can answer plebs' questions, who then zap them for their input.

Examples:

Doctors: #AskDocs

Lawyers: #AskALawyer

Web/App Development: #AskDevs

Need Help Writing: #AskAWriter

Need Relationship Advice: #DatingAdvice #AskAMarriageCounselor

Need General Life Advice: #AskALifeCoach

(Hashtag semantics could be tweaked of course, but you get the idea)

It could also be expanded into freelancing requests, such as:

Need a logo design: #NeedDesigner

Need editing help on a written piece: #NeedEditor

And literally anything else the purple hivemind could think of...

As you can imagine, the depth of which we could take this is infinite. Literally anyone out there with expertise in ANYTHING could bootstrap a hashtag that other nostriches could use if they ever need help. And if lots of other folks do see value in having a channel opened up with a group of experts in that niche, all they have to do is just follow that hashtag, and use it anytime they have a question.

Of course, in order for this to work, Both the experts and the question-askers would have to embrace the concept wholeheartedly, making those hashtags active enough that the experts have enough of a financial incentive to keep that hashtag bookmarked, and actually spend time scrolling through and answering questions. But I think this would fit so well with the Nostr culture, that it has major potential to gain momentum quickly.

We've already seen how popular #AskNostr has been, and that hasn't even had a formal #Value4Value culture around it. It emerged completely organically, exactly how I expect all of these others would, given enough community enthusiasm. Ultimately this whole idea would just be an evolution of the #AskNostr concept—expanding the "#Ask_____" format out to EVERYTHING, with the embedded etiquette that you ZAP those that help you.

Eventually, if it grew big enough, we may see a large enough ecosystem of hashtags emerge that we could have either npubs, or a centralized database that tracks the most popular #Ask_____ hashtags, so the whole community knows which ones are the most active should they ever have a question within that topic. (This would also act as great purple-pilling bait for experts from these fields that aren't on Nostr yet. By joining the protocol, they could then start earning #Bitcoin by participating in this zapping ecosystem, directly with people around the world who are willing to pay for their expertise).

Once this idea gets engrained deeply enough into the Nostr culture, the maintenance of the concept would be quite simple 👇

EXPERTISE-SEEKERS:

- Post your questions, using the corresponding hashtag (ex: for a medical question, #AskDocs)

- Follow good etiquette and zap the doctors who answer your question (perhaps you could also attach a bounty to the note, i.e. "best answer gets a 10K zap")

EXPERTS:

a) Keep tabs on the hashtag corresponding to your field

b) Answer questions

c) Earn zaps ⚡️

d) Optionally, you could also put the hashtag(s) you frequent in your bio, to raise awareness on it (thus bringing more future questions ---> more zaps for you 🔄) so your followers know that's where to go to get advice from you and other experts in your field.

This would be a very interesting free market experiment, which I could see blowing up should both experts and question-askers embrace the idea of an open ecosystem of #V4V help channels.

Since the most obvious example I can think of as a kickoff test would be medical advice from doctors, I will tag in the Nostr docs I know below. I know nostr:nprofile1qqsd7msd66kcej39cpuu0n4ln9jce7gjgz65ck6deyzyytnay95sqhspx9mhxue69uhkummyv5hxxmmfde3hyet9dvhxxmmd9ahx7um5wf3kc6t9de6z7ctsdyhhvvf0wfjkccteqyxhwumn8ghj7mn0wvhxcmmvqy38wumn8ghj7mn0wd68yttkv4exjenfv4jzuam9d3kx7unyv4ezumn9wsacwhjf has already been doing exactly what I talked about above on an individual level (answering dentistry questions to anyone who tags him, in exchange for zaps).

What do y'all think about this, nostr:nprofile1qqstzt0wugc7sklvr8e7fcl7ukyn63ym3ns4nmf2mnk0vqnz4l9x65qpp4mhxue69uhkummn9ekx7mqpr4mhxue69uhkummnw3ezumtfv3jxc6twvuhx67tydeeju6nsqythwumn8ghj7mn0wd68ytn5dacx2arg9e5kuen0te28kw nostr:nprofile1qqsra0r5jp73ly50yz00yy8gwt9vqvl270lcne59x2rdghv3udg7l8spzdmhxue69uhhqatjwpkx2urpvuhx2ue0sv2m5n nostr:nprofile1qqsxknkf3upwv3lqz3qtguammy48lt3puqdk4fkxtcedh99rvzfzwtsppemhxue69uhkummn9ekx7mp0qydhwumn8ghj7un9d3shjtnwdaehgunsd3jkyuewvdhk6tcpzamhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuen0w4h8gctfdchxvmgm0eauz nostr:nprofile1qqszjf0k3vznlcvcw4efurpywfannqkegp69kwccfvz5yzqgft6tukcpzamhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuurjd9kkzmpwdejhgtc8n0pm0 nostr:nprofile1qqst0xtvrqlqxm0j0qpfgkuqh0wgkzl4judkvgdgd0e4d8pnyytlqlgpz4mhxue69uhhwmm59eekjctdwd68ytnrdakszxthwden5te0wpex2mtfw4kjuurjd9kkzmpwdejhgtcpz4mhxue69uhhwmm59eek7anzd96zu6r0wd6qu6c2pf nostr:nprofile1qqsdvyenvujkqs4xwae3se2m78ecmrxaj385h2nvpdcw7jcztx227pqprpmhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuumwdae8gtnnda3kjctvqy28wumn8ghj7un9d3shjtnyv9kh2uewd9hszyrhwden5te0dehhxarj9emkjmn929qg0h? Would you participate in following the #AskDocs hashtag, answering people's questions, and earning extra zaps for it?

I'll leave it here for the Nostr community to discuss. Am I thinking too big, or could this be the next big trend that takes P2P #V4V into another stratosphere?

Share your thoughts below!

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

We could just settle on #AskJason and leave it at that 😜

nostr:npub1v44xa74fd5weq0l4dhpudg8msr7w9m6adr2042p75kx39mqt6y8qeavgf8 you should do #AskACFO

General job titles like #AskACEO #AskACFO #AskAFounder are an interesting idea...

The market of people that would post questions would be small, but if the zap bounties were set really high, there could still be potential there.

Or, it could be more of an AMA vibe where plebs just ask them questions they're curious about.

Worth thinking about!

Yea might be optimal for a place like Stacker.news but the cost to maintain one of those channels can be cost prohibitive to the newer people.

Re: “general” the #AskADoc or writer, etc were all general too.

Personally I see it as a way to initiate or deepen connection with someone you can help.

Whether they zap or not or become a client or not isn’t the thing for me…that’s very transactional.

Whereas, it (sales) should be relational.

It’s about helping someone and fostering relationship through connection

Kicking off #AskDocs now with an inquiry from a friend.

She's having an awful time with a 104° fever, body pain, and plaque in her throat, indicating infection.

I realized that despite all the research I've been doing on health recently, it's been almost exclusively on the preventative side, so I'm not sure what the best course of action is to recommend outside of eating healthy, sun, water, and rest.

Any other good fever hacks y'all would recommend where you've seen good results?

Thanks in advance! 👨‍⚕️⚡️

nostr:nevent1qqsdulpdgn9f6wekzpxuz6whw7n2kxe6ddytxwgs5z09mr0wparr92cpz4mhxue69uhkummnw3ezummcw3ezuer9wchsygqqrzm7uvlmy5uyxcuuvt3f9lk8qznf4yas3m3hf3da49cunvu4vspsgqqqqqqsd8ptqy

Love this idea from a social media perspective! Makes it so much easier for people to connect with experts in an organic way. Would experts also tag the “#Ask___” hashtag in their posts or bios so people can find them more easily? Or do you see a different way for that to happen? Curious how you’d make it seamless for both sides.

The way I visualize it, the experts would primarily:

a) Follow the hashtag so they could scroll it and answer questions

b) Add it to their bio so their followers know where to go to get their questions answered directly from them

No reason for them not to use the hashtag themselves though. Sticking with my doctors example, I'm sure docs would also occasionally have questions to throw at the other doctors in the community, regarding weird patient cases they're stumped on, or stuff like that!

That makes a lot of sense! Following the hashtag and adding it to their bio would make it super easy for people to find them. I also love the idea of experts using the hashtag themselves—it would create a space for them to learn from each other too, not just answer questions. It’d definitely keep things more collaborative and dynamic. Really curious to see where this goes!

Was trying to fix a car issue and all the youtube videos about it were unclear or garbage... except one dude.

One dude in front of his garage, explaining clearly, concisely. Everyone in the comments saying the same thing, that this was the best video about that specific issue, a diamond in the rough..

And it's just some dude who knows about cars in front of his garage.

I remember thinking "damn I wish I could zap him for this one".

You might be onto something

This is an amazing idea 🤯

Good starting idea but AI will make information generation cost obsolete. Need to plan for signal per byte or some other metric to filter noisy floodgates.

#askatreeguy #askafloodtech #askaconstructionsupervisor

At your service.

Potential nostr:nprofile1qqstu7l4mcrgc8vy9mf55lp8q5r7e9q0t6j3vuw06p32jh5ap9pq6zsppemhxue69uhkummn9ekx7mp0qyg8wumn8ghj7mn0wd68ytnddakj7x7zc0r integration here, nostr:nprofile1qqs9nshptttmcz6uj7uy8ze8vwjugz0lw64esk447868cj7d6f0xargpz4mhxue69uhkummnw3ex2mrfw3jhxtn0wfnszyrhwden5te0dehhxarj9emkjmn9qy2hwumn8ghj7am0wshxummnw3ezuurpwf68jvc7lwd nostr:nprofile1qqstsw3gkljwt5stm9svt7htvcjlj4ffze4chkcyt4pxxj30xkgeg5qprpmhxue69uhhwetvvdhk6efwdehhxarj9emkjmn9qyg8wumn8ghj7mn0wd68ytnhd9hx2qgcwaehxw309ac8yetdd96k6tnswf5k6ctv9ehx2aq95gptt nostr:nprofile1qqsyvrp9u6p0mfur9dfdru3d853tx9mdjuhkphxuxgfwmryja7zsvhqpzamhxue69uhhv6t5daezumn0wd68yvfwvdhk6tcpz9mhxue69uhkummnw3ezuamfdejj7qgwwaehxw309ahx7uewd3hkctcscpyug?

Not extremely well-versed in your product, but this concept seems like it would fit beautifully with your P2P nostr/health ethos!

good idea. I’d be down for ophthalmology related topics.

Great idea. ⚡️

#Askafilmmaker

Fantastic idea, I for sure see it becoming something even organically over time on Nostr. Who’s gonna stop it?

#askamechanic got questions about a car problem? I got you

What should you look for when buying a used car?

Make a post with the hashtag 👀

First, research reliability and customer satisfaction for the particular year and model you are looking at. You need to be choosing the correct type of vehicle before worrying about the individual one you’ve located.

Then when you have found a potential purchase, check with Carfax and autocheck to help look for title issues and accidents. Third, if you can afford it and seller is willing to cooperate, I would hire a highly rated local mobile mechanic to perform a full inspection and report on the vehicle.

I'm in! Let's do it

Yeah, that’s just subreddits formed by hashtags. I’ve been saying this for almost 2 years now.

Great minds 🤝

i answered a question once- i don't think they even read it lmao

#AskAMom ❤️

Yes, great one!

I'd be more than willing to give it a shot, although nothing beats being face to face with a patient.

#Aliens dancing with #octopus in deep #space exploration.

Yes! I’ve long wanted a stack overflow with bounties which kind of overlaps. Nostr is the perfect ecosystem. If you pursue this, I’d be interested!

👀

Huh. This got some attention. I was obsessed with this problem 1.5 years ago. Maybe I’ll revisit this.

Good idea. I'm in.

#AskATrainer

You thinking personal training/exercise? I like it...

Love that! You are probably right!! A market place of knowledge…

Let me know if you need a dev

🔥🔥🔥

Great idea all around.

Wonderful idea! Thx for sharing. Think these are some great use cases... i would definitely use #AskATaxExpert and also think it would be great to have for #AskALawyerinFL #AskaLawyerinNV to get specific advice for state laws.

Definitely! Folks would have to put in some #ProofOfWork onboarding experts in those regions in order to get those tags moving, but once they did, it would be a huge value-provider

sounds like Reddit on nostr with lightning/cashu facilitating #v4v proposition

I have somehow still not dove deep on cashu despite hearing about it constantly...got any resource recommendations?

Uers might have to redirect the asknostr questions by putting the correct tag in the comments to bootstrap the correct tag. Perhaps we can even use a bot for this..

Yep exactly, just like how people write an introductory post without knowing about #/introductions, and people that see it tag it in for them to get it populated on that hashtag

xnkdx

I think this is a great idea! I’m happy to answer questions to #AskANetworkEngineer. I’m not really after zaps but just a way to share my expertise and experience as a network engineer with the #nostr community.

Love this! I helped someone with a Networking issue previously on nostr, expecting nothing in return and was zapped when I provided a solution.

This is already more than an idea! "Traction trumps all" is a phrase I love when it comes to this kind of thing.

As I was reading, I found myself thinking of it competing with reddit, and sub-reddit threads. Ie places I actually search for real answers. A product review. Or how to fix a website plugin / edit a podcast. Sooo many topics now come to mind.

Also check out the latest episode I did with nostr:nprofile1qyx8wumn8ghj7cnjvghxjmcpz4mhxue69uhk2er9dchxummnw3ezumrpdejqqgy5y90592trxhy8lju73qdqhwmzhxne25v7zzw0t7wjaashdq0kygy5pn6j who is very eloquent about how he is using systems engineering and AI to be insanely efficient. I wonder if Nostr hashtags could be used to fulfil the micro-tasks he has...?

Open protocols win!

💪

I like this initiative. Try it!

I like it!

Definitely not thinking too big and this is great for making the V4V economy a reality!

Pretty cool idea ngl.

nostr:note1me7z63x2n5anvyzdc95awaax4vdn566gkvu3pgy7tkx7ur6xx24s6jplgu

#AskaTeacher #AskEnglish #AskGrammar

nostr:npub15hh6f7hmz459u70zy70t8gwae64fvkfejsf8cyrezppptjgel5tqnrqufv

Added to my list under #AskAHealthCoach 👍

The potential for this to grow into a self-sustaining #ecosystem is huge. As more experts and seekers join, the hashtags could become go-to hubs for specific niches, creating a vibrant, decentralized knowledge economy. The possibility of a centralized database or npub tracking the most active hashtags is also a great addition, as it would streamline the process for newcomers and help the #community identify trending areas of expertise.

💯🔥 Exactly my thoughts

More and more niche tags would organically emerge as a means of filtering out a lack of expertise.

I'll be following and answering these tags though they won't be as frequently used as askdoc etc 😁 #askgamer #askphilosopher and #askmusician.

I propose we leave out the ask "a" as I showed above, but we'll have to reach consensus on that.

Love this! Thinking too big Ben? Is that even possible? 🔥 🔥 🔥

How about we don’t talk about our medical conditions on nostr and make an app called “mentr” that connects older, injured, or retired experts with people working in projects or finding problems in an area. My mechanic is retiring. All that experience is lost.

Save the experts!

Queried primal and damus for notes with #asknostr and here is what I found on a week basis

It feels like between 2024-22 and 2024-46 the volume there was much less activity on #asknostr

Wondering if there is a free or paid relay that has the full graph and allows for some kind of firehose access?

There was almost 0 on all the other suggested #ask____ tags, a little volume on #askdevs but not worth charting

That was my thought, except I would add the word 'yet.'

All those tags could work in the #future but it's still too early.

It maybe worth preparing though, as long as you're prepared to bet on #nostr going #mainstream.

While the value will all be on the expert side to start, I’d imagine many would do it as a way to give back, sort of like the surgeons that do charity work fixing Cleft Pallet (Operation Smile) and similar ailments. You may need to find ways to “delete” mistakes that could cause real harm, but I’m sure it’s just a technical hurdle. Good luck!

great idea. how about adding #askAI for AI agents to answer questions (AI will want to stack sats too!)?

It hadn’t occurred to me that an npub that aggregates content from a tag could take the place of a group. Multiple admins could share the nsec 🤔 that would control spam. If CSAM became an issue, an AI agent could be run to could filter content first

Great idea. #askakitchenpainter #askahousepainter I used to do this pre bitcoin and earn income giving step by step answers.

Value for value and the world is gonna heal

This is my first post on here. I've known about nostr for 2 years or maybe a little less (1 year?), but i've been looking at it a bit more recently after nostr:nprofile1qyv8wumn8ghj7urjv4kkjatd9ec8y6tdv9kzumn9wsq3vamnwvaz7tmjv4kxz7fwwpexjmtpdshxuet5qqsqfjg4mth7uwp307nng3z2em3ep2pxnljczzezg8j7dhf58ha7ejgqgzx3h s recent beach side conversation with nostr:nprofile1qyxhwumn8ghj7mn0wvhxcmmvqyv8wumn8ghj7urjv4kkjatd9ec8y6tdv9kzumn9wsqzpq35r7yzkm4te5460u00jz4djcw0qa90zku7739qn7wj4ralhe4z6d283f .

The game changer is being a distribution model for speech and content, and I don't see how that happens if people can't receive money for their content PRIOR to offering value.

What I would use, and what I'm trying to build, is a marketplace where things are crowdfunded on a micro level. There's things I would create that would be helpful to others if receiving funds for it were easy. Donating my energy to the miasma of the digisphere for untradeable commodities seems net destructive.

#askabusinessperson

#introductions

nostr:nevent1qvzqqqqqqypzqqqcklhr87e98ppk88rzu2f0a3cq56df8vywud6vt0dfw8ym89tyqqsdulpdgn9f6wekzpxuz6whw7n2kxe6ddytxwgs5z09mr0wparr92chmwqfv

Happy to participate in askscientists but 99% of people who are currently here aren’t going to like the conclusions 😂

Oh boy I would love to know the unpopular truths ⚡️⚡️

great idea - it might be useful to have 2 hashtags - one generic #asknostr and one specifc #ask___ - then you can browse through all the asks which might be quite interesting

I like this idea

This is useful

#hashtags are and #zaps is ecommerce .. peer to peer ..

My Solution: SatShoot.

I got interested in this back when I wanted a P2P market for bitcoin self-custody troubleshooting.

Expanded the idea to general freelancing that became [SatShoot](https://satshoot.com) .

My approach was to introduce a whole new kind(nip description [here](https://github.com/Pleb5/satshoot/blob/main/apps/satshoot/EVENT_STRUCTURE.md) ) for the gig economy because it can capture the use-cases better with specialized tags for title and status of the job(description is the content field), and include any tags related to the topic of the gig with "t" tags.

The best part is that with the new kinds a host of freelance apps can evolve instead of centralizing around kind1 apps, having already very bloated UX problems.

Also, to have the opportunity to assess multiple bids on the gig properly and select the best one, I have a simple "Offer" kind which has amount, payment method and pitch info associated with it. The client takes an Offer which is recorded in the Job kind. This can be thought of as a contract of sorts.

To enhance decentralized discovery of reputable counterparties, I included the option to review each other as client/freelancer, as well as public zaps and nutzaps (built-in Cashu wallet) as payments. Client-side web of trust and outbox model further help with disintermediation.

..Nonetheless I included a feature to extend reach and post Job as a kind1 note for now.

The app, though functional now (and had gigs posted and paid in multiple cases), has been under heavy UI/UX-related development for the past c.a. 2 months, which I hope to share this month.

Ok. I'm building it. It's not an easy project to get right:

- getting the full dataset (as realtime as possible)

- identifying the answers (zaps, reactions, comments)

- allow exploring topics (by tag)

- ensure that people can vote/react from the web-app + their nostr client seamlessly

But I've managed to make a first prototype. Super cool to already see the top #asknostr questions from the last month(s) on nostr which are not that easy to find even if you have nostr:nprofile1qyx8wumn8ghj7cnjvghxjmcpz4mhxue69uhk2er9dchxummnw3ezumrpdejqqgzn9kpsmllqnsf7wh5tz3wgy4cclsftqqplv8tpayrhwgw8llunevgnmdf3 premium.

Onwards!

noice!

Nailed it man.