people are sleeping on ecash and nwc

nwc solves many convenience/ux issues, like automatic subscriptions

ecash vastly improves privacy for day to day payments and allows you to easily diversify your custodial risk by using multiple mints

People who are serious about self custody can run their own mints and issue their own nwc connections - it's not that hard if you're really deep into Bitcoin

And those who are comfortable using custodians for payments (99.9999% of the world) - you can get a 10x UX improvement over legacy rails.

Bullish af

Reply to this note

Please Login to reply.

Discussion

I need to look at it again.

Yes

What I don't understand is how the ecash is secured by actual sats.

Is it possible for mint to issue more ecash than it has on hand?

Admittedly, I have not played with ecash at all.

Yes, mints can (and will) both issue unbacked ecash, AND RUG ecash they did have

Over time, reputable mints will emerge, and they are incentivized by being able to earn transaction/routing fees.

I can appreciate the speed, privacy and efficiency of ecash, but wouldn't we just be rebuilding the central banking model of fractional reserve banking?

Isn't that the inevitable next step that comes with mints?

No, it's completely different, because eventually any mints who do this will get wiped out and there aren't any bailouts

In an open market without rails, sure. But that's not the legislative environment we're heading towards. Keep in mind that failure was on the table for banks also... Until we started bailouts.

I don't actually see any other way, though. We need custodians and this path is more secure than lnbits, for sure.

The way I understand this, for mints to be interoperable, they also need to be lighting nodes, correct?

BULLISH

Wake me up, please !

Any recommendations on some tutorials that walk through this? I’ve listened to discussions but would really value seeing it done in a demonstration. I’m trying to understand more but feel out of my depth compared to others who may be full time in the space.

Start with setting up a lightning node (many guides out there)

Then follow nostr:nprofile1qqs9pk20ctv9srrg9vr354p03v0rrgsqkpggh2u45va77zz4mu5p6ccpzemhxue69uhk2er9dchxummnw3ezumrpdejz7qgkwaehxw309a5xjum59ehx7um5wghxcctwvshszrnhwden5te0dehhxtnvdakz7qrxnfk readme here to install the mint on top

Then congratulations - you now have your own mint

https://github.com/cashubtc/nutshell

Thank you. I am trying to be the Uncle Jim for my friends and family when they’re ready for the orange and purple pills. I can see a lot of applications, but unfortunately my close network isn’t ready for it yet.

Same. For the end user, if I have to trust someone with my money, why would I trust you?

The biggest objection is, "how do I convert it back to cash?"

I feel like there are people today who have a Venmo account with a small balance that they pay back and forth to others with. If the balance gets big, they transfer back to a bank account. If small, they can add from the bank. While I know we have the potential to do things radically different, I think people will feel comfortable with experiences similar to what they know today. I’d love to use ecash the way I use Venmo- and someday I think I will. I take your point on getting back to fiat money- like, could I take a $20 bill from a fiend and send them equivalent ecash? Then, if they want out, they could send me the ecash for whatever that currency is? Imagine a scenario where I get farm products once a week, and distribute to friends and family. Some use cash, others Apple Pay, others Venmo, others Zelle. They want to give me between $6 and $50 per week, depending on orders. I’m open to suggestions- and appreciate the discussion.

Agreed. Venmo is what people recognize and the experience they are after. In that way, Strike still offers the best experience and do it right, imo.

They onboard, and offboard in seamless fashion. They're a Bitcoin company but the focus is on the payment rail, not so much the Bitcoin itself. They offer the ability to hold cash or BTC and seamlessly transfer back to the home bank. They're a bridge. For me, that's what we're missing.

You just can't touch the traditinal banking rail without getting tied up in KYC. That's what most here are looking to avoid. There's just very few ways to do it. Atomic swaps are one thing, but it's expensive. That's for fanatics. It's possible, but that's a hard sell for most. Strike did the regulatory work in that arena and take the cake as far as I'm concerned.

Zeus offers a great solution by making the phone the node and instant 0 config channel to Olympus. Highly underrated.

Until things are priced in sats, people don't seem to have interest in using the Bitcoin network as their bank. Right now, it's still a speculative asset.

Idk. For a small circular economy, lnbits is the easiest to set up and transact fairly private. Ecash is an upgrade from that.

Hopefully others chime in.

Most people want an experience similar to what they have in their physical wallet and online bank account.

Bitcoin’s UX still sucks. Im not a complete idiot and I can keep track of all these different products providing different services. Which ones can I trust? Which ones are used where?

Just like in VC enabled Web3…there are far too many options and none of them make life “easier”

We haven't built the experiences yet, they are only possible in theory

Idk cash app does Bitcoin pretty easy

Bitcoin proper is fine. I’m referring to the ecash / mint / lightning L2 applications.

for one, i cant run nwc with my own mint on a server it can only run in a webapp so its useless to me.. the big custodians didnt release their nwc tricks that i know of. do you?

Not yet. Soon TM

I'm gonna release code soon so any node runner can issue nwc connections to it, the mint can use the same node

The reason why I’m running through the python crash course. I want on this party train

why python?

Easiest to learn.

Best self sovereign way (no alby) to issue nwc?

Nothing I know of but I'm cooking something up

lnbits

Had issues but I'm motivated to give it another go. My hacky thing works, but it's close to just being fake 😅

Has the NWC plugin hit main branch yet?

i dont know. doubt it. ive been running a custom mix but planning a rebuild soon™

Yeah yeah, but what about Monero?

Doesn’t ecash provide a similar level of privacy? Use monero as settlement? 🤷‍♂️

took the words right out of my mouth

The underrated duo fixing Bitcoin’s privacy and usability gaps. Automatic subscriptions? Privacy-first payments? Custodial risk diversification? Why isn’t everyone screaming about this?! Are we just early, or are people missing the blueprint here?

I’ve been lacking on the Cashu research, I need more hours in the day. Or I need to stop sleeping.

I’m really not concerned about using a custodian for smaller balances that are meant for spending. I am concerned about people getting priced out of self custody of a UTXO at all though. I really hope that is solvable somehow in the future when it becomes a problem.

People also sleeping on pull requests 👋😉

Sorry do you have a PR I haven't reviewed for a relay? I can't find anything, sorry if yes

Hi! Yes I do. And my apologies for the cheeky message, I just didn't want to trouble you with a DM.

Here it is, my first PR on a FOSS project. Perhaps I didn't submit it properly? If something is incorrectly done please let me know, it's guaranteed to be ignorance at my end.

https://github.com/bitvora/sw2/pull/1

Thanks for your review! I have updated to resolve the breaking change by adding logic to look for whitelist.json

People are sleeping on everything in general

😴